When I was first speaking with schools about 1-to-1 not long after edition 1 of my book (now in its 2nd edition) was published, two big questions were – Is your school/district wireless? Are you providing students with email accounts? Back then, not every school could respond to both questions in the affirmative.
Now we are seeing more ubiquitous devices including tablets, laptops, smart phones and the complexity that ensues. This previous post went into some of the issues faced by schools when introducing BYOD; the comments provide more depth and ideas as well. Any 1-to-1 or BYOD school is wired now as it would make so sense otherwise. Nearly all schools and districts offer some type of email for students if they are 1-to-1.
Like many, I’ve become intrigued by the concept of flipped learning – an idea even more feasible when students all possess some type of device that is as mobile as they are and which is used to learn, review and synthesize content away from the classroom followed by more indepth social, hands-on learning when back in the classroom. To me, it’s all about learner centricity – if done right. This is a great thing and what we have always wanted – the learner has the resources at his/her fingertips, learning and tools for learning are continously available – and the user-created artifacts of learning are organized and available to the learner at any time.
However, the piece that is also needed is some type of online learning community. Rather than email, which we all know has become a boondoggle in our lives and which students are moving away from in droves, an online learning community can offer a safe, contained space for teachers and students.
I’ll be presenting at NCCE on Friday, March 1 at 2:30 a session entitled “A ‘Cloud’ for Flipped Classrooms” which is all about how implementing flipped classrooms, or really most all technology integration projects, ought to have the cornerstone of an online learning community. The benefits of a learning community include:
- Providing a central space for learning that extends the classroom
- Eliminating “Web 2.0 site of the week” syndrome which results in
- login fatigue (trying to remember which ID and password to use) resulting from all the different applications
- fractured student experiences (having multiple interfaces to know and navigate)
- Preventing email clutter
- Rather than the teacher maintaining lists of internal or external emails, the community uses its own internal messaging
- Messaging can include sending student documents, marking them up, and returning to the student via attachments – trackable and centralized
- Threaded discussions
- Real discussions can occur and be followed
- Promotes collaboration
- Students can work as a whole class or in smaller groups with teacher oversight
- Increased student accountability
- No lost paper – the Internet is everywhere – even at McDonald’s!
- Date and time is stamped with work turned in
- Shared resources
- Everyone sees the links, the resources, the photos, podcasts, etc.
- Assignment posting, turning in
- The assignments and the work are centralized
- Class calendar
- A calendar for the class is available to view events, assignments, assessments, etc.
- Easy interfaces
-
- Students use social media now and most online communities emulate this
- A safe place to learn digital citizenship
-
- Practicing how to be a good digital citizenship using social media in a classroom community can provide real examples of what to do and what not to do, along with teachable moments
- Teachers may wish to implement “L.A.R.K.” a concept from my book
- Digital learning should be L — Legal (adhering to copyright and other laws) A — Appropriate (images and ideas should not be offensive) R — Responsible (taking care of digital tools and resources) K — Kind (knowing how to respect and be kind to everyone in a community)
Full disclosure: I manage a great (IMHO!) product that does all this. But this list above applies in general as well. 1-to-1 needs an online learning community to unleash its true potential.
Your thoughts and comments are welcome!
- Pamela Livingston

You’re right about the need to simplify the interface and reduce confusion amongst learners.
Currently, because I prefer to use only that which is free, I usually set up a blog as a portal/focal point, through which students access activities, information, and LMSs like Edmodo. I’ve set up this combo for a number of different schools and systems, and it works well.
Here’s a parent’s perspective on this topic…My high schooler each night has to access a myriad of sources for teachers’ assignments, instructions, homework resources, etc. They are in 6 different locations: 1 uses edmodo, 3 use personal blogs on different sites, 1 uses google docs, and 1 uses gmail. Then, to get additional information from the school, we must access several locations on the school website and refer to my email for the weekly e-newsletter with additional information. Talk about a fractured experience for both student and parent! Homework/school life would be less harried and disjointed if districts and schools would use an enterprise-wide system where all teachers used the same social teaching and learning site. Good luck on your presentation, Pamela!
Thanks James and Debbora. I see these ideas are making some sense to you both, hopefully to others. James, interesting what you’ve done to solve this. I expect your students don’t have a factured experience in your class.
Debbora this is exactly what I experienced when my daughter was in high school. It’s easy enough to lose paper assignments and worksheets; we believe, in theory, making learned have an electronic face solves this. Instead it means multiple IDs, passwords, interfaces and trying to remember it all — and get work done. Instead one teacher had a Moodle page (standalone not part of the districts), another used a Wiki, another had a teacher Web page that was never updated, some had nothing. Supporting your student is complicated and even more complicated, and fractured, for the kid.
- Pamela
I believe Epic-Ed, a US Ed sponsored online community for schools to share their digital transition journey, might consider hosting this community discussion. Epic-ed is also the location of the only user contributed database of US public schools with 1:1, BYOD/T, e-book/smartbooks, and other innovations. Please register at http://epiced.org and put your school and your district on the map at https://www.epiced.org/epic-schools
How might you phrase the goal statement(s)?