The Sky is Falling!

As many of you have may have seen by now, there is a viral video that shows the relent­less bul­ly­ing of a 68-year old bus mon­i­tor by what appear to be mid­dle school stu­dents.  The stu­dents are ter­ri­bly cruel, and the video goes on for 10 min­utes.  At the time of writ­ing this post, the YouTube video has been seen by over 7 mil­lion view­ers and increas­ing quickly.  The main­stream news media has also picked up on this story and it has gen­er­ated con­ver­sa­tions about the nature of youth in our coun­try. It cer­tainly seems that when some­thing awful like this hap­pens, we (espe­cially the media) dwell on the neg­a­tive.  Our soci­ety seems to suf­fer from the “The Sky is Falling!” syn­drome as can be evi­denced by one com­ment under the video.

Every time I watch this video, my faith in the future gen­er­a­tion wilts away slowly. So these are the future lead­ers? I may as well say good­bye now.

As awful as the expe­ri­ence that appears in this video, the pos­i­tive response online has been over­whelm­ing.  The “Lets Give Karen — The bus mon­i­tor — H Klein A Vaca­tion!” web­site was cre­ated in an effort to raise $5,000 to send Karen on a vaca­tion.  Cur­rently, the site has raised  nearly $650,000 from over 26,000 donors. No, those num­bers were not typos!

So what does this have to do with tech­nol­ogy in education?

The Sky is Falling!” com­plex I men­tioned above seems to be extremely preva­lent when in comes to tech­nol­ogy in edu­ca­tion.  We, and espe­cially the media, seem to con­stantly focus on all the neg­a­tive things hap­pen­ing with tech­nol­ogy.  Schools block YouTube because of videos like this.  Face­book is seen as evil at many schools because of the harass­ing that may occur, or because of inap­pro­pri­ate rela­tion­ships between stu­dents and teach­ers.  Social media in gen­eral is con­sid­ered a very dan­ger­ous place for students.

We often don’t con­sider the pos­i­tive things hap­pen­ing with all of those tech­nolo­gies.  What about YouTube videos that have allowed stu­dents to cre­ate a global audi­ence? How about the teacher who dras­ti­cally increased com­mu­ni­ca­tion with stu­dents through a class Face­book page? I con­stantly find myself chal­leng­ing schools to help their stu­dents cre­ate a pos­i­tive dig­i­tal foot­print rather than teach­ing their stu­dents to be invis­i­ble online. Does your school oper­ate with a “The Sky is Falling!” men­tal­ity, or does it chal­lenge stu­dents to cre­ate a pos­i­tive dig­i­tal footprint?

Nick Sauers

3 comments

  1. Holly says:

    Thank you for this post, Nick. It seems so hard to turn the con­ver­sa­tion around to the pos­i­tive some­times, espe­cially when the media jump on these sto­ries and make us feel like this is hap­pen­ing every­where, thereby “nor­mal­iz­ing” bad behav­ior. We recently asked our mid­dle school stu­dents to guess how many kids are cyber­bul­lied every year, and based on what they had seen, read, and heard most of their guess were in the 70–95% range. “It’s every­where!” they said. When we shared the actual sta­tis­tics from the Pew Inter­net study on Teens, Kind­ness, and Cru­elty on Social Net­work Sites that puts the num­ber at 8%, they were shocked. Nat­u­rally, this led to a great dis­cus­sion about what bul­ly­ing really is, and the unin­tended con­se­quences of inflat­ing sta­tis­tics, and we opened a whole new can of things to talk about, which was fan­tas­tic. Unfor­tu­nately, the very next day a local news­pa­per, report­ing on a dra­matic, headline-grabbing cyber­bul­ly­ing story, com­pletely mis­quoted that very same study, say­ing 88% of all kids get cyber­bul­lied online. ACK! So frus­trat­ing. Thank you for encour­ag­ing us as edu­ca­tors to look beyond ‘The Sky is Falling!’ men­tal­ity. I think we need to be doing the same thing as parents.

  2. Nick Sauers says:

    Your com­ment is so true! The media seems to love to por­tray tech­nol­ogy as the vil­lan! Too often, peo­ple don’t put the num­bers or real facts to the story.

    Nick

  3. Holly says:

    Exactly! I can’t tell you how many times I said to my stu­dents this year, “We’re not really even talk­ing about tech­nol­ogy here. We’re talk­ing about human behav­ior.” Or, “this isn’t about Face­book, it’s about social power.” I’ve fallen vic­tim to The Sky is Falling men­tal­ity myself on occa­sion, but there are so many more inter­est­ing things to teach and learn when we get our fear out of the way. Thanks, Nick!

    Holly

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*


*