BYOD Questions to Consider

The buzz in 1-to-1 right now is about BYOD — Bring Your Own Device — and it’s not a fad and it’s not going away. There’s a con­ver­gence of fac­tors caus­ing it including:

  • Hard­ware is diverse and at price points that are more affordable
  • Schools are hyper bud­get conscious
  • The “cloud” (pre­vi­ously called The Inter­net, the Web and the Infor­ma­tion Super­high­way) is ideal for core apps which are free or inex­pen­sive with such as Google (although be sure to use GAFE), and Zoho
  • Par­ents are real­iz­ing that a dig­i­tal device is nec­es­sary for learning
  • Schools want to be sure stu­dents pos­sess 21st Cen­tury skills

But BYOD upsets apple carts right and left. We’ve been build­ing school infra­struc­tures for a long time that have sup­ported a data-centric model in that IT direc­tors allow or dis­al­low devices on the school net­work accord­ing to a set model which is partly about good design and sup­port, partly about sup­port­ing what already exists and partly about not tak­ing on new projects or approaches that require more work, resources, and skill sets. And I’ve been a tech direc­tor in schools so know first­hand that open­ing a can of worms when it impacts the net­work, the laptop/desktop stan­dard­iza­tion, and the hard­ware replace­ment plan is not some­thing many peo­ple will relish.

But then there are the stu­dents. They grow and develop and move to the next grade level and out the door to col­lege and to life. They need to be empow­ered and learn in an envi­ron­ment that encour­ages them to think and write and research and pub­lish and present and ana­lyze and cre­ate new ideas and solu­tions to prob­lems. They also need to own and under­stand the vehi­cles used for learn­ing. So this might mean BYOD.

In order for BYOD to work well there must be a strong part­ner­ship between admin­is­tra­tion, Board mem­bers, teach­ers, tech­nol­ogy, stu­dents, and par­ents. Every­one is going to be impacted by 1-to-1 no mat­ter how it is imple­mented, whether BYOD or a stan­dard hard­ware plat­form either pro­vided or spec­i­fied by the school or dis­trict. But with BYOD it’s likely you are going to see some push­back from tech­nol­ogy peo­ple because of the com­plex­ity, change, work, plan­ning and resources required. So here are some ques­tions to consider:

  • Have you vis­ited a BYOD school or district?
    • If not a team with rep­re­sen­ta­tive stake­hold­ers should do so armed with lots of questions
  • Are you already using Google or Zoho or some cloud solution?
    • With­out cloud apps BYOD is going to be nearly impos­si­ble to imple­ment in a mean­ing­ful way
      • You need the entire school/district com­mu­nity to be able to com­mu­ni­cate, pub­lish, present and share centrally
  • How will you define BYOD?
    • Will there be a min­i­mum device or specification?
    • Will smart­phones be one of the devices?
  • How’s your net­work — is it ready for
    • Wifi every­where with mul­ti­ple roam­ing wire­less devices
    • Cen­tral­ized data secu­rity (Bar­racuda, Light­speed, etc.)
  • How will you address logistics?
    • Will stu­dents be charged with keep­ing their devices charged, ready and safe/secure?
    • Will you have “loaner” devices?
    • Will devices be locked up somewhere/somehow dur­ing lunch, tests, sports?
  • How’s your curriculum?
    • Are teach­ers already used to assign­ments in Google and in using online social media tools so that stu­dent work is already free of hard­ware require­ments — and hap­pen­ing in “the cloud”?
  • How’s your dig­i­tal cit­i­zen­ship education?
    • Do stu­dents already know how to keep a respect­ful appro­pri­ate dig­i­tal footprint?
      • In my book I talk about L.A.R.K. — tech­nol­ogy use by stu­dents should be L — Legal, A — Appro­pri­ate, R — Respon­si­ble, K — Kind
  • How’s your com­mu­ni­ca­tion chan­nel with par­ents, students?
    • If the device is pur­chased, main­tained, repaired and man­aged by par­ents and stu­dents, it’s going to be impor­tant to com­mu­ni­cate often and well
  • How’s your budget?
    • Unless you have planned fully for the changes of BYOD you might be blind­sided by some upgrades or unex­pected costs so make sure to ask these ques­tions when you are vis­it­ing BYOD schools

There are ter­rific schools that have been BYOD for years, The Harker School in San Jose comes to mind for instance. Many peo­ple I respect have been writ­ing about BYOD includ­ing William Stites who posted this blog post for Edu­ca­tional Col­lab­o­ra­tors early this year, Lisa Nielsen who wrote about debunk­ing BYOD for T.H.E. Jour­nal and a recent arti­cle in Dis­trict Admin­is­tra­tor starts with a quote from Lucy Gray who I respect very much — this entire arti­cle by the way is an impor­tant read. The Lap­top Insti­tute which is highly rec­om­mended will have threads this sum­mer in Mem­phis on BYOD.

BYOD can be a solu­tion if you do your plan­ning and home­work and try to fig­ure out up front exactly what you’re get­ting into and plan care­fully. You’ll want to be ready to rethink your net­work as not being about enabling a few mod­els of spe­cific con­trol­lable devices but instead as a path­way to the cloud where your school/district-wide learn­ing com­mu­nity resides.

- Pamela Livingston

22 comments

  1. RG says:

    Great arti­cle. Our school, the newest in our rel­a­tively small county has the best IT infra­struc­ture, but even then it would be over­whelmed by hun­dreds of stu­dents log­ging on to the network.

    But that brings me to two other ques­tions to con­sider:
    1. School board pol­icy. The admin­is­tra­tive team and teach­ers at my school would have no prob­lem allow­ing for some BYOD usage, but our school board pol­icy pro­hibits this. I’m not sure we can per­suade them to change their poli­cies at this time.

    2. Even if we were able to change pol­icy, the issue of equity between schools would arise. Some of our older schools don’t have the IT infra­struc­ture to sup­port BYOD while oth­ers do.

    We’re hop­ing that we can move towards BYOD, but I think we’re still years away in our system.

  2. Cary Harrod says:

    We’re almost through our sec­ond year of our BYOL pro­gram and although it’s been an enor­mous endeavor, I wouldn’t trade it for any­thing! We are see­ing small glim­mers of hope for learn­ing spaces that reflect what it really means to learn…where stu­dents own the learning…where pas­sions are unleashed. You can learn more by read­ing this arti­cle: http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/1105/journal_201105/#/24. We also have a web­site that is in the process of being re-imagined but feel free to check it out: http://fhsdppl.wetpaint.com. It is my belief that we are all in this together and so, should work along­side each other to make sure we’re suc­cess­ful. Thanks so much, Pam, for the work you do!

  3. RG yes if the Board has poli­cies against BYOD that will be an obsta­cle. I won­der when and why they wrote the poli­cies. Was it to pre­vent cell phones? Were they wor­ried about the integrity of the net­work? Were they con­cerned that stu­dents would bring in devices that might be stolen? When would be inter­est­ing too to see what hap­pened before the pol­icy — it may have been before apps went online. The equity between schools can be a tough one unless you decide to pilot at one loca­tion and fig­ure things out when it’s more of a win-win in terms of infra­struc­ture. Good luck and thanks for commenting.

    Cary thanks for you com­ments. The arti­cle brings up two areas I didn’t — PD for teach­ers, and the equity issue. Most definetely fac­tors in suc­cess, and things to be addressed. I think you have another great exam­plar there in For­est Hills, OH — pre­pare for vis­i­tors (grin.) Thanks very much for shar­ing both links.

    It feels now like the next gen­er­a­tion of 1-to-1 but with­out plan­ning and really think­ing it out we won’t see suc­cess. 1-to-1 can’t be about the device it has to be about edu­ca­tion and what hap­pens in the class­room and how hav­ing a dig­i­tal assis­tant 24/7 enhances teach­ing and learning.

  4. Adam Heckler says:

    Good arti­cle!

    I work for a K12 tech­nol­ogy out­sourc­ing firm that’s been deal­ing with a lot of these issue recently (tak­ing schools to GAFE, try­ing to build up wire­less infra­struc­ture, and so on). In fact, our lead engi­neer wrote a blog post about it not too long ago that’s quite sim­i­lar to this one. You can read it here if you want: http://bit.ly/xbJ7cb

    Thanks!
    – Adam

  5. Pam Livingst says:

    Thanks, Adam, for this link. I like how your lead engi­neer goes more in depth into the tech­ni­cal side of things. This must be addressed for BYOD to work well. Hop­ing the tech folks will look closely at your link and at the chal­lenges of BYOD along with the advan­tages to school­wide seam­less learn­ing through the cloud.

    It’s great that the com­ments here have fur­thered and deep­ened the infor­ma­tion from the orig­i­nal post.

    - Pamela

  6. Excel­lent arti­cle. will be sure to retweet.

    Our school is in year one of BYOT with a vol­un­tary trial while we burn in the sys­tem, give teach­ers a chance to play and work on lessons/curriculum in prepa­ra­tion for 1:1 BYOT next year (with finan­cial sup­port for iden­ti­fied stu­dents who can­not bring their own device).

    I like the break­down of infra­struc­ture and class­room issues. We had two years of prepa­ra­tion and con­ver­sa­tion before we were ready to make this move.

  7. JD you bring up a great point — finan­cial sup­port for stu­dents who can­not afford BYOD (or BYOT.) Hav­ing man­aged 1-to-1 with finan­cial sup­port, I would sug­gest a way to not make the finan­cial sup­ported device the same one, so kids don’t notice “oh that’s for the poor kids” (not my think­ing at all — just a repeat of what I’d heard.) OR maybe schools think­ing this way can buy in bulk sev­eral mod­els, offer them to par­ents who aren’t sure what to pur­chase at the cost the school paid, and sub­si­dize some of them as well. Stigma is some­thing to always try to avoid.

    Thanks for extend­ing the con­ver­sa­tion!
    – Pamela

  8. Steve Hayes says:

    Great arti­cle! You and your read­ers are wel­come to join #BYOTchat on Twit­ter every Thurs­day at 9 PM (ET). For more info visit byotchat.com

    Thanks!

  9. Steve thanks for the hash­tag great to know about this. I will stop by and hope oth­ers read­ing these com­ments will also

    - Pamela

  10. […] BYOD Ques­tions to Con­sider | 1 to 1 Schools […]

  11. […] Pamela Liv­ingston was orig­i­nally posted on the blog 1 to 1 Schools. To see the ini­tial post, please click here. Pamela Liv­ingston is the Pro­fes­sional Devel­op­ment Man­ager on the K-12 Team here at […]

  12. It’s amaz­ing how quickly the par­a­digm has shifted toward bring your own device. In Octo­ber 2010 I wrote this post for 1:1 Schools and at the time, BYOL seemed like a for­eign con­cept. http://1to1schools.net/2010/10/going-against-traditional-wisdom/
    I still remem­ber that stan­dard­iza­tion was the key fea­ture of a 1:1 pro­gram. Our school is now in our third year of a BYOL envi­ron­ment and we con­tinue to improve the qual­ity of teach­ing and learn­ing daily. We stopped hav­ing the dis­cus­sion about stan­dard­iz­ing devices and have moved for­ward. It now seems pretty nat­ural. BTW — The Amer­i­can School of Bom­bay which has had a lap­top pro­gram for over ten years has decided to move to BYOL for next year. I con­sider them to be a leader in edu­ca­tion for today’s world and this is a land­mark deci­sion in my mind. They cer­tainly have the resources to con­tinue to do what they doing. They have decided that this change is best for their stu­dents. No turn­ing back now. Thanks, Pam for the post.

  13. Blair, I remem­ber your post­ing and some of the ear­lier dis­cus­sions. I knew about ASB going to BYOL but not that your school was as well. It solves the issue we had when I ran a 1-to-1 schools — stu­dents leave/surrender lap­top. The par­ents then would call me right away for the rec­om­mended model because once a stu­dent is using a dig­i­tal assis­tant con­tin­u­ally for learn­ing it becomes like a right hand and can’t sud­denly be sev­ered just because of grad­u­a­tion or mov­ing to another school.

    Thanks for join­ing the conversation,

    Pamela

  14. Shabbi Luthra says:

    ASB is an estab­lished 1-to-1 Tablet PC pro­gram for ten years and we’re going BYOD next year in all MS/HS grades as well as optional BYOD in grades 4 and 5. We’ve been work­ing towards it for a while. We had to first move most of our soft­ware to the cloud so the tran­si­tion was easy. There’s a lot of excite­ment and buzz at the school about the move. The tech dept is excited too as man­age­ment of devices now shifts to own­ers and they’re work­load is reduced and their work is trans­formed. They can actu­ally now take a sum­mer break!

  15. Shabbi, thanks so much for adding that link to the con­ver­sa­tion. ASB is indeed a highly-respected long-established 1-to-1 loca­tion and your going BYOD gives more evi­dence to the hard­ware inde­pen­dent “tip” now hap­pen­ing in schools. Look­ing for­ward to see you at http://www.laptopinstitute.com and to your par­tic­i­pa­tion in the “Prac­ti­tioner Panel” we’ll be hav­ing in one of the sessions.

  16. […] BYOD Ques­tions to Con­sider is an arti­cle by Pam Liv­ingston set­ting out ques­tions which she rec­om­mends that schools con­sider when plan­ning for Bring Your Own Device to incor­po­rate pupil-owned devices in teach­ing and learning. […]

  17. […] Help­ful Link Posted on June 27, 2012 by hale5244 The Ohio School Board Asso­ci­a­tion posted this link on their Twit­ter feed this morn­ing. Our school it… […]

  18. […] devices includ­ing tablets, lap­tops, smart phones and the com­plex­ity that ensues. This pre­vi­ous post went into some of the issues faced by schools when intro­duc­ing BYOD; the com­ments provide […]

  19. […] ubiq­ui­tous devices includ­ing tablets, lap­tops, smart phones and the com­plex­ity that ensues. This pre­vi­ous post went into some of the issues faced by schools when intro­duc­ing BYOD, the com­ments pro­vide more […]

  20. I am not cer­tain the place you are get­ting your infor­ma­tion, but
    great topic. I must spend a while study­ing more or fig­ur­ing out more.
    Thanks for fan­tas­tic info I was search­ing for this info for my mission.

  21. It is actu­ally faster to copy from server to local and
    then back to server again. How­ever, the 3d ani­ma­tion soft­wares are high-priced,
    par­tic­u­larly, apps made by well-known com­pa­nies spe­cial­iz­ing
    in gen­er­at­ing ani­ma­tions. A keen inter­net user will always remain on the look out of a good qual­ity new soft­ware to upgrade
    his system.

  22. Today, I went to the beach­front with my kids. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daugh­ter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She placed the shell to her ear
    and screamed. There was a her­mit crab inside and it pinched her ear.

    She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is totally off
    topic but I had to tell someone!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*


*

synthroid online pharmacy synthroid online no prescription buy synthroid online valtrex online pharmacy buy valtrex online valtrex no rx zoloft cheap buy zoloft no prescription cheap zoloft can you buy lamisil online lamisil online without prescription lamisil online overnight prozac online no prescription buy prozac online without prescription buy prozac buy propecia overnight propecia online pharmacy purchase propecia order priligy online without prescription buy priligy online no prescription buy priligy online no prescription cheap lasix online lasix online no prescription buy generic lasix online buy generic tadalafil online buy tadalafil online tadalafil online no prescription buy retin-a online without a prescription retin-a online without prescription retin-a online pharmacy cheap sildenafil online sildenafil online without prescription buy sildenafil cheap online order strattera online buy strattera online buy strattera no prescription buy neurontin online with mastercard neurontin online pharmacy order neurontin online without prescription buy cheap nolvadex nolvadex online without prescription buy generic nolvadex can you buy zovirax online zovirax online no prescription buy zovirax