Choosing the right “device”

I need to start this post off with a dis­claimer.  I am not, and never have  been, a tech­nol­ogy direc­tor, nor do I have any sort of tech­nol­ogy degree.  My for­mal edu­ca­tion  has been in edu­ca­tional method­ol­ogy, cur­ricu­lum, and lead­er­ship.  My career in K-12 edu­ca­tion was spent as a teacher and then prin­ci­pal.  Many of you who read this blog know lots more about the “nuts and bolts” of tech­nol­ogy than I do.

My learn­ing around tech­nol­ogy has occurred through hands on tin­ker­ing, work­shops, and learn­ing through peers.  In my cur­rent posi­tion, I often speak and write about tech­nol­ogy inte­gra­tion, and how lead­ers need to use tech­nol­ogy to move schools for­ward.  Because much of my work now deals with tech­nol­ogy, I do get the “nuts and bolts” types of ques­tions.  Fre­quently, I can’t answer those ques­tions, but I can refer the ques­tion to one of the amaz­ing tech­nol­ogy con­tacts I have.

One ques­tion that I do get asked very reg­u­larly by schools con­sid­er­ing one-to-one is, “What type of device should we pur­chase?”.  The answer to this ques­tion can turn into a heated debate between many in the one-to-one world.  Many edu­ca­tors swear by Macs while oth­ers believe lap­top PCs are the answer.  Net­books and tablets have also entered into the debate about the best one-to-one device.

My answer to this ques­tion isn’t what many deci­sion mak­ers want to hear.  I really believe that “it depends”.  I have worked with enough one-to-one schools and talked with enough one-to-one edu­ca­tors to say that dif­fer­ent schools have had suc­cess using var­i­ous devices.  It is extremely unlikely for the device to make or break a pro­gram (unless of course the device was a total lemon!).

When I’m talk­ing or writ­ing about tech­nol­ogy tools, I often say that ask­ing what tools we should teach edu­ca­tors is the wrong ques­tion.  We need to start by ask­ing what skills we want them to be able to teach, and then align tools with those skills.  I feel the same way about one-to-one devices.  The con­ver­sa­tion should not start with decid­ing what device to pur­chase.  The con­ver­sa­tion instead needs to start by ask­ing what YOUR school intends to accom­plish with one-to-one.  After you can clearly artic­u­late that, you can find a device that best meets those needs.  Obvi­ously, there may be sys­tems and infra­struc­ture com­po­nents that come into your deci­sion.  With that in mind, I would still much rather choose a device based on learn­ing needs and goals than infra­struc­ture and com­pat­i­bil­ity.   That may cer­tainly lead to addi­tional costs upfront, but it will also ensure that tech­nol­ogy serves your stu­dents needs rather than just the eas­i­est or cheap­est route to take.

Please feel free to leave your com­ments.  I know that many of you are very pas­sion­ate about a cer­tain device, and I’m fine with that.  You are pas­sion­ate because the device has worked very well for you!  Other schools in sim­i­lar cir­cum­stances may cer­tainly want to hear your views.

Nick Sauers

6 comments

  1. I haven’t had 1 to 1 for very long but I’ve found that hav­ing a bunch of dif­fer­ent devices serves some great pur­poses. Kids get exposed to dif­fer­ent devices since I have a PC, net­books, iMacs, and iPads. Kids can do just about any­thing they want because each device has its own strengths, which helps make up for their weak­nesses. While I do pre­fer Macs and I love my iPad I don’t mind PC’s and the net books are pretty handy because they are so com­pact, slow, but the size is just right. And all those devices work on our net­work with no prob­lems! Why choose just one device?

  2. Jane Flaey Smith says:

    Loved this! Check out “Lev­el­ing the Play­ing Field” http://www.joyzabala.com/Documents.html
    We are using this SETT for­mat in Iowa for stu­dents with dis­abil­i­ties as we con­sider assis­tive tech­nol­ogy to help them met their IEP goals. It is great, really focuses on the stu­dent and their learn­ing needs first.…last are the tools. I plan to share your arti­cle on Twitter.

  3. Jane Faley Smith says:

    Typo-Jane Faley Smith

  4. Mary Ann Guidos says:

    The con­ver­sa­tion instead needs to start by ask­ing what YOUR school intends to accom­plish with one-to-one.“
    Agreed! This deci­sion is about the tech­nol­ogy but there are other impor­tant con­sid­er­a­tions:
    1. Teacher ped­a­gogy. What do their class­rooms look like? What is their style of teach­ing?
    2. Con­tent. Will kids be writ­ing? Doing lots of research? Need oppor­tu­ni­ties for dif­fer­en­ti­a­tion of mate­r­ial.
    TPCK is a good resource when con­sid­er­ing what device(s) to choose. http://tinyurl.com/3cqyyk

  5. Lori Nelson says:

    Great post, Nick.You make a great point about being clear about your goals and pur­pose before choos­ing a device. If you are inter­ested I wrote a post about my expe­ri­ence with the iPad thus far. We are con­sid­er­ing it for a 1:1 ini­tia­tive at our 5–8 mid­dle school. http://www.lori-nelson.blogspot.com

    Alfonso, I really like your idea of not lim­it­ing your­self to one tool. Then stu­dents learn the impor­tant les­son of select­ing the right tool or tools for a given task.

  6. […] type of device should a school/district imple­ment if going one-to-one?  Nick Sauers writes on his blog about the choice needed to be less about the phys­i­cal machines, but rather the intended use. What […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*


*

synthroid online pharmacy synthroid online no prescription buy synthroid online valtrex online pharmacy buy valtrex online valtrex no rx zoloft cheap buy zoloft no prescription cheap zoloft can you buy lamisil online lamisil online without prescription lamisil online overnight prozac online no prescription buy prozac online without prescription buy prozac buy propecia overnight propecia online pharmacy purchase propecia order priligy online without prescription buy priligy online no prescription buy priligy online no prescription cheap lasix online lasix online no prescription buy generic lasix online buy generic tadalafil online buy tadalafil online tadalafil online no prescription buy retin-a online without a prescription retin-a online without prescription retin-a online pharmacy cheap sildenafil online sildenafil online without prescription buy sildenafil cheap online order strattera online buy strattera online buy strattera no prescription buy neurontin online with mastercard neurontin online pharmacy order neurontin online without prescription buy cheap nolvadex nolvadex online without prescription buy generic nolvadex can you buy zovirax online zovirax online no prescription buy zovirax